Ideas on method
“Fair enough.” It is hard for a teenager to express stronger approval.
That was my students’ verdict after the first year of the maieutic method. It had all started in 2018: I devoured Daniele Novara’s Cambiare la scuola si può in two days and immediately enrolled in the year-long course at his Centro Psicopedagogico in Piacenza.
You start from a stimulus situation and a question chosen by the students. Quintilian gave us “Why does too much closeness breed contempt?”, the carpe diem ode “Is there any room left to believe in tomorrow?”, a song by Daniele Silvestri “When can we say that time flows sideways?”. The answers came as videos, street interviews and debates.
It was not the first method I had tried. At the time I had already worked on the flipped classroom, on laboratory teaching and on PBL, as far as I remember, and on other things that are, let’s say, a bit archaeological today. With Daniele Novara I also learnt a way of dividing my students into working groups that is a little more developed than the ones we form in class, out of haste or necessity, without thinking too much. Since then, always with Daniele’s permission, I have also trained other schools in his method when they found his approach interesting.
In any case, let’s be clear from the start: it is not possible to adhere completely and exclusively to a single teaching method or a single pedagogical model. In my view, every teacher who wants to experiment effectively has to build a solid toolbox, holding many different methods to use with the different students and classes that will come before them over a career.
Today we perhaps have an umbrella, Universal Design for Learning, UDL, which helps us say that there are multiple ways of passing on knowledge, of interacting, of acquiring and of giving back. All very true, but then it has to be visible in practice.
So alongside Daniele Novara I immediately place Nancie Atwell, the visionary teacher who brought the Writing and Reading Workshop back into the spotlight, but also, much more simply, Fogarolo and Guastavigna, with their work on teaching and learning with maps, Castagna, with films in teaching, and Baccalario and Magnone, with storytelling in secondary school. We could go on with debate, as De Conti and Giangrande describe it, passing through a rather more particular pedagogy such as Giusti’s Insegnare con la letteratura, or Castoldi, with planning, assessment and certification by competences, and a few ideas from across the ocean with Lemov.
And the best thing of all, at least from my point of view, is that none of these methods is exclusively digital. Over time I have learnt this too: teaching built on digital tools does not suit every pupil. So always being able to combine analogue parts and electronic parts, to use a rather old-fashioned term, is perhaps a further sign of the versatility that, in my view, every teacher must be ready for.
All this, and more, is what has marked and still marks my career. I may risk sounding less than humble, though I am not, and my students could vouch for it, but I realise that over these years the most evident trait of my teaching has been an experimentalism I call tireless only because of the energy I have put and still put into it, and which those close to me in my career have surely noticed. A need for discovery that I have felt and still feel, constantly, driven by the wish to reach my students better and better and to do my job better, tempered by the certainty of never succeeding as much as I would like.